Skip navigation

One of the joys of collecting photo books (which I have been doing for about 30 years)  is that new books can be placed side by side with other books in the collection—a pleasure especially when the new book proves to be “better” than the previous ones.  What makes one book “better” is a judgment based on personal tastes—but , in general, printing quality, the selection and ordering of the photographs, and (occasionally) a well written essay can all add to the experience of a new book.

Unfortunately, I live in Fairbanks, Alaska, far from a good bookstore (by which I mean something on the caliber of the Strand in New York, or Powell’s in Portland—both stores I love to browse in when opportunity allows)—so I mostly acquire books by purchasing them on line based on their descriptions on web site—which means that the book must be purchased before it can be seen.  But the arrival of a package with books is always a bit of an event—a first meeting, always hopeful, but sometimes disappointing.

Yesterday, I arrived home to find an package on my front stoop—it had been there for hours, so the books had chilled to the ambient twenty below—I had to bring them inside and warm them up for several hours before removing the shrink wrapping (otherwise the water from the air would condense and warp the books)—two volumes—the new “Gypsies” by Koudelka, published by Aperture, and Vivian Maier “Street Photographer” published by PowerHouse.

I have a copy of the 1975 version of Gypsies in my collection (softbound, second printing) and might have skipped purchasing the new edition had it not gotten such rave reviews from readers on the Amazon site—which it fully deserves.  The new edition has nearly twice as many pictures, and they are printed larger and with a gritty matt surface.  The energy of the book is more intense—the addition of many of the new pictures adds to my appreciation of the care with which Koudelka framed his pictures, and the love he shows for his subjects.

Josef Koudelka, Gypsies, Romania, 1968

I have also been looking at a new book Sunder by Bruce Haley (who I met in China a few months ago)—this is his first book—he is not nearly as famous as Koudelka—but the images are from Romania and other countries in eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union, and many of them seem to reflect a similar sensibility of the people of eastern Europe.  Koudelka’s Gypsies was shot in the 1960s, Haley’s work was made between 1994 and 2002, but both bodies of work seem to come from a much more distant past.  Koudelka clearly is working with a marginalized segment of society in the east block countries before the fall of the wall, but Haley seems to showing a broader devastation caused by a dysfunctional society.  That so many could be left so far behind seems sad beyond words.

Bruce Haley, Sunder 2011

And while I tend not to read (and especially not re-read) most essays in photographic books (Szarkowski and Robert Adams emphatically excepted), Sunder has a stunning essay by Andrei Codrescu about his life and travels in Romania.  Codrescu’s voice is familiar to me from his stories on NPR, and the essay about the “revolution” (the quotes are his) is chilling.  His voice allows us to feel the repression and fear that runs through the photographs of both Haley and Koudelka.

The Vivian Maier Street Photography book is the product of one of the most successful PR campaigns I have ever witnessed about a photographer—I first heard about her work about a year ago—and the story is amazing.  Maier worked as a nanny for most of her life (the cover photo even makes her look somewhat like Mary Poppins), who spent her free time making photographs on the streets of Chicago, leaving behind an archive of more than 100,000 negatives.

These negatives were discovered by John Maloof, who has worked to scan these images and present them in this book.  Maier died a few days before Maloof attempted to locate her, which adds an odd hook to the work—unrecognized during her lifetime, declared a genius after she dies.

Eight of the images in the book are self-portraits—a proportion Lee Friedlander would be proud of—but whether this represents a true proportion of her effort in self portraits, or an attempt by the editor to present us with a sense of Maier (I suspect the latter) is not clear.  Maier does not appear to be a happy person—perhaps a reflection of her own station in life—she never married—never had children of her own—and was (we suspect) always held responsible for the age appropriate (i.e., terrible)  behavior of the children in her charge—at a time when children were to be seen and not heard.

Vivian Maier, Street Photographer, 2011

My favorite pictures in the book are of children that may have been those in her charge (pages 14 and 15) (what is that girl—oh, no—it’s a boy with a coonskin hat—holding in his hands—it’s not a grenade (as in the Arbus image)—but what the hell is it?)  And I suspect (though of course there is no way to verify this) that the boy grew up to be a hedge fund manger—his look of distain and his carefully arranged escape route (that open car door) make it clear that he is  a lot smarter than the rest of us—born that way, of course.  And the picture opposite—like a Harry Potter scene—a girl hold a Mason Jar with—well, what is it—it obviously can’t be captured by a camera—a frog?

The book feels a little uneven to me—not all the pictures are as strong as the best images—but there are more than enough strong pictures (and details within pictures) to justify the publishing of the work.

All in all, a good evening in looking at books.

Advertisements

4 Comments

  1. Hi Dennis! Glad to find your blog online – I was looking for images of the Tanana and found you that way – the bottle crate photo and the tire photo came up. How are things going up in the north country? I’m in Anchorage, and still making work. Send word!

    • denniswitmer
    • Posted January 1, 2012 at 3:26 pm
    • Permalink

    Karen

    Good to hear from you–I was admiring the piece of yours I have just a few days (weeks?) ago…

    Do you have a web site?

    Dennis

    • Marvin Falk
    • Posted January 2, 2012 at 1:37 pm
    • Permalink

    Dennis,
    Have you seen the “Time’s best of 2011: The Photobook’s we loved”? — I found the selection of over 20 books engaging, as was some of the commentary. I would be very interested in your take on this.

    Marvin

  2. フルラ エナメル バッグ


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: